Latham & Watkins Partners: Corporate Leaders Should Prepare for a New Era of Congressional Scrutiny
This article originally appeared on Fortune.com.
Ed Siskel, Nick McQuaid, and Vanessa Le are partners at Latham & Watkins, where they advise companies facing congressional investigations. Siskel was White House Counsel to President Biden. McQuaid was Deputy White House Counsel to President Obama. Le was lead investigative counsel for the Majority at the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence.
Within hours of Democrats winning control of both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections, Representative Robert Garcia, the incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee, delivered a two-word warning to potential investigative targets: “Lawyer up.” Corporate leaders would be wise to heed that warning too.
Seasoned oversight members in the House and Senate are already telegraphing their investigative priorities and targets. And when Democrats take control of Congress in January, their ability to legislate will be constrained by a Republican President with veto power. Instead, investigations will offer lawmakers a way to pursue their policy priorities, demonstrate accountability, respond to the economic frustrations that helped propel them to victory, and provide a message testing ground for the 2028 presidential election.
The implications for CEOs and boards extend well beyond partisan politics. Companies often face questions not only about whether they have complied with the law, but also about their business decisions, political relationships, and internal communications. Congressional investigations create reputational harm and resource drain—and they can spur state-level enforcement and regulatory activity—even without any proof of misconduct.
What companies should do now
While Democrats will not officially take control for another six weeks, lawmakers are re-issuing letters from months ago with a renewed verve. Past history on an issue is the best indicator of where committees will start in January: staff have already done the legwork on these issues and received member sign-off, where necessary. And paying close attention to issue areas (e.g., donations to Administration priorities) or sector-wide issues affecting an industry (e.g., hyperscalers and data centers) can provide an early warning of scrutiny to come. Government affairs teams and trade associations should be providing ground truth into how lawmakers view a company or industry.
Another priority is understanding what records exist and where, with congressional investigators increasingly seeking emails, text messages, encrypted messaging application chats, and other communications involving senior executives and board members. Companies should review their document retention policies, ensure employees understand their preservation obligations, and consider whether sensitive business decisions are discussed over informal messaging channels. A casual exchange between executives can take on an entirely different meaning when displayed during a congressional hearing.
Companies also need to get their response team in place now. Internal legal, government affairs, and communications teams too often approach these situations in silos, despite the interdisciplinary nature of congressional investigations. A legal strategy designed to limit disclosure may prolong a damaging public fight, while an effort to quickly resolve a political controversy can create problems with regulators or in subsequent litigation. These tradeoffs are easier to navigate when the right people are at the same table from the outset. And companies should consider whether they need to add key external resources to support their response strategy and retain those resources.
Congressional oversight does not have to be inherently adversarial, but preparation is key to ensuring that companies can navigate the reputational, legal, and potential enforcement risks that can accompany investigative activity.
The Democratic oversight agenda is broad and cross-jurisdictional
Because the Administration has signaled its intent to stonewall congressional investigators, Congress will go after the private sector actors who can act as proxies for their policy priorities and may have the non-governmental end of important communications. Private sector entities and individuals who aren’t the target of investigations can still find themselves as important third-party sources of information, or even as “friendly” witnesses in hearings: all of these interactions create resource drain and pull attention from running a business.
While companies with financial relationships to President Trump, his family, or his administration are obvious investigative targets, the coming wave of investigations will not stop there. Affordability, a defining issue of the midterms, will likely drive scrutiny across industries. For example, data centers could face questions about their impact on household electricity bills and their relationships with utilities and municipalities. Artificial intelligence companies and social media platforms may face pressure over safety and protecting kids online, while financial institutions should anticipate questions about market fairness and financial regulation, including private credit, cryptocurrency, and prediction markets.
Interestingly, several of these issues have bipartisan appeal. Children’s online safety, financial market practices, and consumer costs are not just Democratic concerns. Companies that have avoided taking controversial political positions may nevertheless find themselves at the center of investigations driven by broader economic frustrations.
Because several of the oversight themes cross traditional committee jurisdictional lanes, House Democratic leadership has signaled its intent to distribute investigative responsibilities across more committees. In both the House and the Senate, committees will draw on existing teams of experienced investigators, and may try to recruit additional staff to help drive an ambitious agenda, including former federal prosecutors and law firm attorneys. The House and Senate operate under different rules and possess distinct investigative authorities, so responding to one inquiry won’t necessarily satisfy another. Companies could find themselves navigating competing demands for documents, testimony, and executive attention from multiple committees and from both Houses of Congress.
The consequences won’t end with Congress
Congressional investigations are driven in many ways by public optics and media attention. Policymakers who cannot legislate are using hearings, subpoenas, and document disclosures to draw attention to their priorities. Consequences can quickly extend beyond the headlines: regulators and enforcement authorities closely follow congressional proceedings, and information that emerges during an investigation can trigger additional scrutiny, shareholder litigation, or other private lawsuits. And the ecosystem also works in the reverse, with congressional investigators often pulling issues from ongoing litigation or state regulatory activity.
The new Congress will be sworn in on Jan. 3, 2027, starting a two-year clock for Democrats to highlight and execute on their accountability and affordability agendas; this will happen mostly through oversight investigations, as Democrats deal with a lame-duck Administration. Companies that use this time to understand their vulnerabilities, prepare their records, and establish a coordinated response will be far better positioned than those that wait for the first subpoena.